Inter corporate loans and investments law times journal. Mca has issued a circular yesterday regarding applicability of section 372a companies act 1956. Borrowing cost from company laws perspective vinod kothari. Mar 05, 2015 section 372a of 1956 act covers only body corporate, whereas section 186 of the 20 act covers perons and body corporate. All the four transactions are frequently taken place in any company and henceforth the section becomes more important and therefore it requires to special heed by virtue of strict penal provisions. Cos act 20 section 186, 372a register mb2 of loansguarantee. Accordingly, it put restriction on loan to employees beyond the specified limits 1956 act. The restriction is imposed to check misuse of multiple layers of subsidiaries for diversion of fundssiphoning off funds. In a jv company wherein the indian listed company is providing know how and in lieu of that the jv company is allotting shares of 25%. Have included the probe of slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Lesson 16 intercorporate loans, investments, guarantees and. The new law also throws up a conflict as between section 179 and 186 in the matter of precedence very similar to the question which was raised between section 292 and section 372a in the 1956 act once the latter provision was introduced in the statute book by the companies amendmentact,1999 with effect from 31. Section 372a of the companies act,1956 corporate law forum. Board of india act, 1992 and covered under such class or classes of companies as may be.
Oct 24, 2019 section 186 of companies act, 20 provides that intercorporate investments not to be made through more than two layers of investment companies was not required section 372a of the erstwhile companies act, 1956. Applicability of section 372a companies act 1956 abcaus. The companies act, 20 has been notified in the official gazette on 30th august, 20. Section 372 a of the companies act, 1956 deals with the inter corporate loan and investment. Loans to directors section 185 of the companies act, 20 2. Section 185 of the act, amongst other matters, states that no company shall, directly or indirectly, advance any loan to any other person in whom the director is interested or give any guarantee or. The companies act, 1956 did not spell out the importance of the role of promoters of a company nor had a general definition of this expression as applicable to the whole of the companies act, 1956, except for a definition, limited to a specific section, contained in clause a of sub section 6 of. Amendment of the companies act regulation, 2011 102kb pdf 5 february 2014. The word person has not been defined under the 20 act. Section 372a of the companies act legal service india. There was no such provision in the erstwhile companies act 1956 see section 372a of. The issue hos been examined with reference to applicability of section 372a ol the companies act, 1956 visavis section 185 of the companies act.
The companies act, 20 passed by the parliament has received the assent of the president of india on 29th august, 20. The term company law in simple words mean legislation relating to companies. As per section 2 31 of the income tax act 1961, person includes. In pursuance to the provisions of section 1861 of the act, a company shall make. In this connection, it is hereby clarified that registers maintained by companies pursuant to subsection 5 of section 372a of companies act, 1956 may continue as per requirements under these provisions and the new format prescribed vide form mbp2 shall be used for particulars entered in such registers on and from 1. Introduction to company law cs executive companies act 20. In terms of the provisions of section 372a of the companies act, 1956, the approval of shareholders is sought for confirmation and ratification of the resolution passed by the board of directors as above. Whether this will amount to investment under the provisions of section 372a of the companies act, 1956 for the listed company. Section 1861 of the 20 act earlier allowed a parent company to form two layers of investment companies, while there was no restriction on the number of operating companies.
Effect of conversion on legal status schedule 3 amendment of laws a. Loan, guarantee, security, investment made vinod kothari. Comparison of section 186 of companies act, 20 and. There are changes that may be brought into force at a future date. The development of company law in india is quite historic. Companies compliance certificate rules, 2001 view download. Analysis of section 186 pursuant to companies amendment act. Section 372a inter corporate loaninvestmentguarantee. The intention of both the provisions is by and large identical namely to regulate primarily intercorporate investments and loans.
Sep 22, 2014 the new law also throws up a conflict as between section 179 and 186 in the matter of precedence very similar to the question which was raised between section 292 and section 372a in the 1956 act once the latter provision was introduced in the statute book by the companies amendment act,1999 with effect from 31. Section 287 is a pervasive section and would apply to all classes of companies including investment companies covered in section 1861. Borrowing cost from company laws perspective vinod. The issue has been examined with reference to applicability of section 372a of the companies act, 1956 visavis section 185 of the companies act, 20. Subsection 1 of 186 of the act says that a company shall make the investment through not more than 2 layers of investment companies. Restriction on making investment through not more than 2 layers. Section 372a of the 1956 act, governed public limited companies and private limited companies that were subsidiaries of public limited companies. Section 372a8c and d of the companies act, 1956, specifically exempts any loans made and any guarantee given or security provided by the holding company to its wholly owned subsidiary.
As per section 231 of the income tax act 1961, person includes. Whereas section 185 of the companies act, 20 prohibits guarantee given or any security provided by a holding company in respect of any loan taken by its subsidiary company except in the ordinary course of business. Erstwhile corresponding section 372a of 1956 act was. Investments by company section 185 and 186 of companies act, 20 procedural aspects, carve outs, implication of violations, etc. Companies act 2014 value added tax consolidation act 2010 interpretation act 2005 capital acquisitions tax consolidation act 2003 stamp duties consolidation act 1999 taxes consolidation act 1997 succession act 1965 international treaties. Under the companies act, 20 inter corporate loans and.
In this connection, it is hereby clarified that registers maintained by companies pursuant to sub section 5 of section 372a of companies act, 1956 may continue as per requirements under these provisions and the new format prescribed vide form mbp2 shall be used for particulars entered in such registers on and from 1. Sep 19, 2016 investments by company section 185 and 186 of companies act, 20 procedural aspects, carve outs, implication of violations, etc. The explanation provided in section 372a of companies act, 1956 to the effect that loan includes debentures or any deposit of money made by one company. Provisions as to certain loans which could not have been made if sections 369 and 370 were in force. The companies act, 20 has been notified in the official gazette on 30th august, 20 but the provisions of this act shall come into force on such dates as the central government may notify in the. Power of central government to make rules effective from 12th september, 20 1 the central government may, by notification, make rules for carrying out the provisions of this act. Nov 20, 20 mca has issued a circular yesterday regarding applicability of section 372a companies act 1956. Impact of companies act on private companies, one person. Considering the relevancy of the study we can curtail it to the old act, i. Section 186 of companies act, 20 loan and investment. Some of the provisions of the act have been implemented by a notification. Though years have passed, the number of amendment made to 20 act envisages us to call it as new act. Section 186 in the companies act 2014 herein after referred to as the act corresponds to section 372a in the erstwhile 1956 act.
Changes that have been made appear in the content and are referenced with annotations. Companies acts section 185, 186 and 372a ambiguities come. Lesson 16 intercorporate loans, investments, guarantees. Feb 17, 2014 the issue hos been examined with reference to applicability of section 372a ol the companies act, 1956 visavis section 185 of the companies act. Companies disqualification of directors under section 2741g of the companies act. Companies declaration of beneficial interest in shares rules, 1975 view download. Under the companies act, 20 inter corporate loans and investment plays a very vital role for the growth of industries as there is result in the flow of funds for the group companies or other companies who are in the need of funds. Act requires that companies falling within specific categories. The business of the annual general meeting shall include a the consideration of the companys statutory financial statements and the report of the directors and, unless the company is entitled to and has availed itself of the audit exemption under section 360 or 365, the report of the statutory auditors on those statements and that report. Section 186 of companies act, 20 loan and investment by. Comparison of section 186 of companies act, 20 and section.
An act to reform company law and restate the greater part of the enactments relating to companies. Section 185 and 186 loans and investments by company. For giving up free hand to the industries, a drastic change was made. Be it enacted by parliament in the sixtyeighth year of the republic of india as follows.
This circular will apply till section 186 is notified, and if and when section 186 is notified, there will be again ambiguity as section 186 does not grant exemptions in holding and wholly owned subsidiary cases like section 372a does. Further, the exemption available from the provisions of section 372a of the 1956 act to private companies as well as loans or investment given or made by. Section 372a8d of the companies act, 1956, provides that the limits specified in the section would not apply to any guarantee given or any security provided by a holding company in respect of loan made to its wholly owned subsidiary. There was no such provision in the erstwhile companies act 1956 see section 372a of companies act 1956. Mca clarification on section 185 of ca 20 qua section 372a. Companies act 2014, section 186 irish statute book.
Section 186 of the companies act,20 and its comparison with. Companies act 2006, section 1097a is up to date with all changes known to be in force on or before 07 may 2020. The companies act, 1956 did not spell out the importance of the role of promoters of a company nor had a general definition of this expression as applicable to the whole of the companies act, 1956, except for a definition, limited to a specific section, contained in clause a of subsection 6 of. Section 6 act to override memorandum, articles, etc. Limitation of period to incorporate close corporations or convert companies 3. The act consolidates and amends the law relating to companies. Companies acts section 185, 186 and 372a ambiguities. The companies act, 20 hereinafter known as act has come with a change in the theory of loan and investment by company. Companies act 1956 the act and rules made there under, seeking the approval of its members in terms of section 272a of the act. Mca clarification on section 185 of ca 20 qua section. In which it has been clarified that section 372a,which deals with inter corporate loans remain effective till section 186 the companies act,20 notified by the mca. This an act to consolidate and amend the law relating to companies. Companies act no 71 of 2008 872kb pdf maatskappywet no 71 van 2008 685kb pdf companies amendment act, no 3 of 2011 2mb pdf companies regulations, 2011 pages 1 107 3,1mb pdf companies regulations, 2011 pages 108 212 4,2mb pdf companies regulations, 2011 pages 2 320 6,5mb pdf memorandum on the objects of the companies.
Section 186 of companies act, 20 provides that intercorporate investments not to be made through more than two layers of investment companies was not required section 372a of the erstwhile companies act, 1956. Analysis of section 186 pursuant to companies act, 2017. However, the companies shall also consider applicability of the restrictions under section 185 dealing with loan to directors etc. Loans and investments in companies act, 20 unraveling the. Loan and investment by company companies act 20 section 186. In computing at any time the percentages specified in sub section 2 and the provisos thereto, the aggregate of the investments made by the investing company in other body or bodies corporate whether before or after the commencement of the companies amendment act, 1960 65 of 1960, up to that time shall be taken into account. Section 372a 8c and d of the companies act, 1956, specifically exempts any loans made and any guarantee given or security provided by the holding company to its wholly owned subsidiary. Companies act, 1956 bare acts law library advocatekhoj. Previously regulated by voluntary standards and norms, the. Section 185 section 185 of the companies act, 20 has been delved upon and to make it comprehensive, the circular dated 14.
Clarification on section 185 of the companies act, 20. Please select the section section 1 short title, extent, commencement and application. The new act provides that intercorporate investments not to be made through more than two layers of investment companies. Section 372a of the companies act, 1956, specifically exempts any loans made, any guarantee given or security provided or any investment made by a holding company to its wholly owned subsidiary. Companies act 2014 value added tax consolidation act 2010 interpretation act 2005 capital acquisitions tax. Companies act, 20 some issues requiring urgent actions. The enactment of s724 and s5 of the companies act, no. Section 372a of 1956 act covers only body corporate, whereas section 186 of the 20 act covers perons and body corporate.
In terms of section 372a of the act, the making of investments or giving guarantees or providing security in connection with a loan and. Section 372a interpretation and application chapter 7. Clarification on section 372a of the companies act, 1956. Amendment of the companies act regulation, 2011 560kb pdf 20 august 20. Section 186 1 provide that without prejudice to the provisions contained in this act,20 a company shall unless otherwise prescribed, make investment through not more than two layers of investment companies. Section 372a of the companies act, 1956 the act deals with intercorporate loan, investment, guarantee and securities in connection with loan.
An act to consolidate and amend the law relating to companies and certain other associations. Companies act 2014, section 607 irish statute book. Further, the exemption available from the provisions of section 372a of the 1956 act to private companies as well as loans or investment given or made by a holding company to its subsidiary company are no longer. X x x x extracts x x x x b extracts may be taken therefrom and copies thereof may be required, by any member of the company to the same extent, in the same manner, and on payment of the same fees as in the case of the register of members of the company. Section 3a members severally liable in certain cases section 4 memorandum. There is no such condition in section 185 of companies act, 20 and section 372a of companies act, 1956. Companies disqualification of directors under section 2741g of the companies act, 1956 rules, 2003. Section 372a of the ca 1956 was applicable only to public companies. Penalty for contravention of section 369, 370 or 370a. Related parties under the companies act, 20 part 1 an amendment has been made in the definition of.
205 474 533 435 408 1141 185 767 565 1271 103 605 959 1292 1363 88 1193 1186 1216 979 349 282 270 1466 428 626 1362 746 823 317 163 1216 1383 256 1073 58 816 837